The Buffalo Gazette
Restaurant Reviews
by
Mike Niman & Laura McClusky
Buffalo Gazette Culinary Arts Critics

Please Note: These Reviews Date Back to 1999-2001.
Most of These Restaurants Have Since Gone Out of Business as Indicated Below.
The Buffalo Gazette Has Ceased Publication.


Editorial Statement (1998)

We began writing restaurant reviews because we were angered by the geographic exclusion of inner-city restaurants from local restaurant guides published and distributed by other local newspapers and tourist & visitor agencies and organizations.  Because of this senseless policy, some of the region's best restaurants were excluded from area guides while mediocre suburban eateries and corporate cookie cutter chain restaurants were included.  We teamed up with the Gazette to review Buffalo's hidden gems, our often overlooked locally owned and operated neighborhood eateries.  Most of the restaurants we review provide first class ethnic cuisine at down home Buffalo prices.  All of the restaurants we review provide unbeatable authentic neighborhood ambiance.  Together, you have good food and friendly interesting hosts -- the foundation for a memorable eating experience. 

The results so far have been great.  The Gazette offers more than double and triple the readership of the papers that redline inner-city restaurants.  Readers, it turns out, want to try new types of food and visit new neighborhoods.  Traffic in some restaurants has increased three-fold after a Gazette review, helping to build our community economic base while building community through great eating experiences. Please vote with your money and support local businesses.

It is our policy not to publish bad reviews.  If we don't like the food, we don't waste space in the newspaper writing about it.  We move on to the next restaurant and find food worth writing about.  We're not in business to tell you where not to eat -- we're here to share our discoveries with you!  We don't use a silly star system to rate food -- we tell you about the food.  Our reviews are qualitative, not quantitative -- you can't assign a number rating to food and you can't compare apples to oranges.

We often review new restaurants.  Unfortunately this is a difficult business and roughly 3/4 of the restaurants that open will fail within two years, hence many restaurants listed here have closed despite excellent food and often despite a strong customer base.  We retained the reviews as encouragement for these entrepreneurs if they decide to give it another go.

Enjoy!


Anacones (Bailey Ave. - Bar - Sandwiches)

Amy's Place (Main St. - Lebanese Food)

Andre's Closed

Aunties Jamaican Restaurant (Main St) *Highly Recommended! Take out. Clinton Street Location is now closed. Main Street (north of 198) Location is open.

Bubba's Seafood (Jefferson Ave.)

Caffee's Closed 

Caribbean Experience (Bailey Ave.- Jamaican Food) 

El Fogon Closed

Elijah's Closed

Endrito's Burritos (Excellent Burritos)

Hollywood Burrito Closed

Ike & BG's Rib House (Geneseee St. -Smoker Cooked Bar-B-Que Ribs)
*Highly Recommended! Take out only. Currently (12/04) only open Wednesday through Saturday. Still the Best!

Ivette's Closed

Lougus' (Genesee St.- Italian) Closed

Lydia's Pearl (Pearl St) Closed

Meister's (Hertel Ave.- Steak)

People's (River Road / Middle Eastern) Closed 

Pho 99 (Niagara St./City Hall - Vietnamese) *Highly Recommended.

Pho Hong Closed

Randy's Red Door Closed

Soulfabulous (Bailey Ave. - Soul Food - Ribs)

Tim's Soul Food Closed

This is It! (High St. - Soul/Southern Food)

Tropical Bakery (Grant St. - Puerto Rican Food) *Highly Recommended Closed

Vargas' Comida Criolla  Closed

Wishbone Bar-B-Que (Niagara St. - Puerto Rican Food)

 


Send E-Mail to Mike & Laura,
the Gazette's Restaurant Reviewers


Buffalo Gazette On-Line Restaurant Reviews are hosted by
mediastudy.com
All Contents Copyright 1999-2001 Buffalo Gazette
Page Updated Dec. 2004